The Broadway show All My Sons became profitable today, mostly thanks to Katie Holmes, Ted Casablanca writes on E! Online. John Lithgow and Dianne Wiest co-star, but "as talented and praiseworthy as those two veteran stars may be, worth drooling over on stage, they are not," writes Casablanca. While other shows are closing, the revival of the Arthur Miller play has recouped its $3.25 million investment. (More Katie Holmes stories.)